Skip to content
Diagnosing Schizophrenia Case Study Creative Writing Ideas Fourth Grade Personal Statement Examples For University Journalism Free Custom Writing Sheets Creative Writing Exercises Worksheets Increase Essay Word Count Essay All You Need Is Love Application Letter For Service Crew In Jollibee Sample Letter Of Application For J2 Employment Authorization Essay About Taking Notes Spanish Essay Checker Application Letter To Join The Army Cover Letter For Cv On Email Apa Format Citing An Essay Application Letter Nursing Manager Creative Writing Programs In Colorado Job Application Cover Letter Closing Writing A Personal Statement For Graduate School Examples Writing A College Personal Statement Research Paper With Cover Page Thesis Title Proposal For Education Perfect Essay Writers Term Paper Topics Terrorism Research Paper On Argument Topics Essay Scholarships For High School Graduates Help With An Essay Outline Personal Statement For Research Position Example Write Technical Report Creative Writing Lessons Poetry Personal Statement Structure Residency Academic Writing Jobs In Nairobi Case Study Of International Business With Examples The View From 80 Essay Placement Papers Of Syntel 2010 Freelance Writing Jobs Seattle Wa Research Paper Topics Criminal Law Biology Coursework Variables Best Persuasive Speech Topics For College Students Uw Admissions Personal Statement Cover Letter Examples For Gym Jobs Creative Writing Scholarships Nyc Essay Service Cyprus Cover Letter Resume Student College Admission Essay Funny Consulting Case Study Structure Creative Writing 2011 Ut Austin Essay B Buy Stamp Paper Online Delhi Argumentative Essay Type 1 Essay Topics Edgar Allan Poe Apa Qualitative Research Paper Outline Argumentative Essay On Abortion Critical Thinking 4th Edition Pdf Personal Statement Sample Essays Scholarships Essay On Geometry In Daily Life Coursework Info Turnitin Persuasive Essay Graphic Organizer Pdf Application Letter United Nations Persuasive Essay Examples For High School Students Sociology Papers Topics Foundation For Critical Thinking Press Location Free Uk Essays Online Youtube Classification Essay Cover Letter Legal Secretary Position Essay Grading Software Mac Best Research Topics For Thesis Essay Questions Jekyll And Hyde Essay Questions On Death Of A Salesman Argument Essay Sample For Gre Examples Of Compare And Contrast Essays 5th Grade Annotated Bibliography With Multiple Authors Example Of An Paper In Apa Format Example Of Application Letter For Teacher Fresh Graduate Cover Letter For Healthcare Receptionist Cover Letter Format Cornell Sample Application Letter Bartender Job Research Paper In Biology Topics Critical Reasoning Test 6 8th Grade Narrative Essay Examples Essay Development Science Technology Critical Thinking Training For Managers Professional Writing Services Los Angeles Critical Thinking Lesson Plans Middle School Job Application Cover Letter Hr Scientific Research Paper Outline Example Cover Letter For Job Application And Resume Analytical Essay Conclusion Essay About Yourself For College Buy Professional Resume Templates Creative Writing Ma Teesside Case Study Mystic Monk Coffee Essay Comparing French And Russian Revolution Writing A Descriptive Essay On A Person Top Creative Writing Mfa Programs Uk Comparative Essay The Yellow Wallpaper Personal Statement For Graduate School In Speech Pathology Writing A 5 Paragraph Essay Graphic Organizer Creative Writing Continuing Education New York Nyu Creative Writing Schedule Letter Of Intent In Real Estate Narrative Essay Experience Is The Best Teacher Best Sample Cover Letter Job Application Personal Essay Introducing Yourself Essay On Social Exchange Theory Research Essay Sample Thesis Sample Background Research Paper For Science Fair Writing Rubric For Expository Essay Apa 6 Sample Essay Case Study On Banking Law Essay Writing In English Free Download Sample Essay Topics For College Entrance Essay On Jokes Essay Scholarship Ideas Case Study About Youtube Academic Freelance Writing Companies Essay Writing Vocabulary Esl English 101 Essay Sample Pay To Do My Statistics Homework Act Essay Score 8 Case Study Child Labour Need Help With Science Homework How To Write A Physics Lab Report Abstract Essay For Med School Critical Thinking Activities For 1st Graders Critical Thinking Worksheets For 3rd Grade Viperchill Blog Case Study Crm Best Practices A Case Study Of An Indian Private Bank Cover Letter Examples Wharton Cover Letter For Resume Yahoo Essay Words To Start A Paragraph Essay Of 350 Words How Do I Write A Great Essay Narrative Report Writing Definition Kids Essay Contests 2011 Purchase Pre-written Essays Gre Analytical Writing Practice Tests Developmental Psychology Critical Thinking Questions Literature Review On Human Resources Planning Argumentative Essay Questions And Answers Economics Research Paper Database How To Write A Policy Development Paper Case Study About Narcissistic Personality Disorder Pay People To Write Your Papers Annotated Bibliography For Law School Tips For Writing A Narrative Essay Ocr History Coursework Guidance Document Cognitive Psychology Term Paper Topics Creative Writing To Kill A Mockingbird 5th Grade Science Critical Thinking Worksheets Critical Thinking Challenges Middle School Personal Statement Phd Management Case Study Hindi Meaning Creative Writing Phd Canada Case Study Medical Tourism Research Paper Topics Video Games Essay About Technology And Society Job Application Cover Letter Name Essay Types And Elements Personal Assistant Cover Letter Template Free Aadsas Personal Statement Guidelines Cover Letter Email Customer Service Mexican Culture Essay Free Alcohol Coursework Research Papers Topics For Electronics And Communication Sample Statistics Coursework Architecture Personal Statement Comments How To Write Cover Letter Salutation Opinion Essay Matura Rozszerzona Application Letter Project Engineer Essay Questions On The Death Penalty Reflective Essay Topic Ideas Case Study Theeyeshaveit.com Book Exchange Dar Essay Contest Winners 2012 Writing Cause And Effect Essay Outline Xerox Tqm Case Study Persuasive Essay Topics For 6th Graders Writing A Great College Admissions Essay Scientific Expository Essay Topics The Homework Helper Request Letter For A Promotion Apa Style Research Paper 2011 Good Introductions For Essays Examples Cover Letter Download Example Quotes For Personal Statement Personal Statement Advice Medicine Dbq Essay Great Depression Critical Thinking Moore Parker Mba Dissertation Case Study Cover Letter Sales Support Assistant Playful User Interfaces Literature Review And Model For Analysis Essay Describing My Best Friend Creative Writing Mfa Blog Mla Style Research Paper Bibliography Research Paper Map Psychology Ethical Case Study Examples Essay Writing Ielts Task 2 How To Write A Cover Letter Without Company Name Apa Literature Review Setup 8th Grade Science Research Paper Outline 5 Paragraph Jane Schaffer Essay Outline Critical Thinking Skills In Life Narrative Essay Beginning Middle End Essay Topics On Beowulf One Way To Organize A Comparison And Contrast Essay Is Term White Paper Definition Writing Analysis Report Paying Someone To Write A Paper Mla Format Research Paper Example 2012 Sample Application Letter Bank Branch Change Essay On Global Warming In 500 Words Application Letter Closing Remarks Essay Of Fast Food Nation Essay Writing Tips Persuasive Biology Related Personal Statement Nikola Tesla Research Paper Thesis Creative Writing Programs Canada University Art History Research Paper Thesis Example Unique Persuasive Essay Topics Argumentative Essay Against Technology Essay On The Yellow Wallpaper Feminism Sample Cover Letter For Internship Uk Creative Writing Graduate Programs Ny Best English Essay Example Essay Writing Why Elks Americanism Essay Contest 2011 Cover Letter Analyst Uk Cover Letter To Or Dear Mla Research Paper Daly Cell Phones Case Study Template Document Transition Words To Use In Essay Writing Request Letter For Driver Essay Describe Yourself Sample Literature Review History Example Free Essay On Internet Privacy Critical Thinking Is Useless Common Application Essay Rules Sell College Essays Online Cover Letter Dear Vs To Apa Research Paper Third Person Academic Papers For Sale Books To Help Essay Writing Analysis Of John Stuart Mill#39s Utilitarianism Personal Statement Scholarship Engineering Texas Tech College Essay Topics Cover Letter If You Do Not Know Name Animal Research Report Template Elementary Creative Writing For 7th Graders Argumentative Paper Topics High School Writing A Good Thesis Statement Ppt Customer Is Not Always Right Essay Annotated Bibliography Science Example Term Paper Topics On Computer Science Case Study Analysis Of Nestle Cover Letter For Veterinary Position Annotated Bibliography Example Mla Form No Essay College Scholarships 2012 Phd Thesis Writing Help In India Request Reference Letter Template Creative Writing List Ideas Critical Thinking Questions To Ask Kids Hsbc Case Study Essay Group 1 Essay Nageswara Rao Essay Topics For College Essays Literature Review In Job Satisfaction List Of Creative Writing Exercises Cover Letter Zs Associates Case Study House 22 Structure 5 Paragraph Essay Going To The Movies Academic Research Proposal Example Essay Type Test Ppt Critical Thinking Unit 1 Past Paper Free 3 Paragraph Essay Graphic Organizer Research Report Indesign Template Topics To Write An Persuasive Essay On Case Study Perioperative Nursing Narrative Essay Examples High School Cover Letter Engineering No Experience Leave Application Letter For Village Gcse Science Coursework Writing Frame Student Cover Letter Download Essay Example Pmr English 8 Critical Thinking Questions Opinion Essay Topics Pdf Writing Research Papers Book Best Buy Home Exercise Equipment Cover Letter Customer Service Samples Essay Spanish Meaning James Dyson Case Study Marketing Chicago Manual Of Style Research Paper Sample Mla Citation Lecture Notes Best Cover Letter Investment Banking Critical Thinking Company Raleigh Nc Graduate Entrance Essay Examples Sample Cover Letter Business Analyst Job Definition Essay Over Honesty 11th Grade Research Paper Requirements Cover Letter Graphic Design Writing A Personal Statement For Nurse Practitioner School Oedipus Essay Written While High How To Write Personal Statement For Scholarship Pdf

Win Some, Lose Some

In bad news, I got called a moralistic, over-wrought navel-gazer. In good news, blog stats are up and visits have quadrupled in the past few days. I’ll take it! Welcome new readers, hope you remembered to bring your bongs.

I decided not to weigh in over there since I felt trying to defend myself or challenge interpretations of what I’d written wouldn’t add anything productive to a conversation that was about much more than my post, and which was moving along fine without me. I do want to add something about what was seen as an overly-dramatic use of the word “trauma.” I don’t have a problem being called dramatic. (I am, after all, a gay, and we take pride in our dramatics, even if, on occassion, as Danny Noriega would say, “Some people weren’t liking it.”) But I did want to say that in my use of that word, I’m drawing from a body of literature that might be of interest — in addition to Cho’s work, I’m thinking of David Eng and David Kazanjian’s Loss, Saidiya Hartman’s Lose Your Mother and E. Ann Kaplan’s Trauma Culture.  Some of these and other recent works on race and trauma draw from psychoanalytic theorists Nicholas Abraham and Maria Torok, and their notion of “transgenerational haunting,” as well as sociologist Avery Gordon’s Ghostly Matters: Haunting and the Sociological Imagination.

And, in related news, the mayor of Los Alamitos, a small city in Orange County, CA, sent an email postcard to a colleague that featured the White House lawn as a field of watermelons, with the note “No Easter Egg hunt this year.” When the recipient, an African American woman who volunteers with the city, objected, the Mayor explained he was unaware of any racialized content in the image. He stated, “Bottom line is, we laugh at things and I didn’t see this in the same light that she did. I’m sorry. It wasn’t sent to offend her personally – or anyone – from the standpoint of the African-American race.”

13 Comments

  1. That watermelon patch -White house lawn job was exactly the very first “Obama joke” I was told, by my cousin, at Thanksgiving.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 12:23 pm | Permalink
  2. As a generally overwrought navel-gazer myself, I wondered how you were taking things over here.

    And while outside of sociology, I’d add Shoshana Felman and Dori Laub’s Testimony to the list. That book changed the way I thought about a lot of things.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 12:36 pm | Permalink
  3. Nothing celebrates the genocidal conquering of the Americas like a racist joke!

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 1:13 pm | Permalink
  4. Eh, where’s the florid prose? Anyway, thanks for the references and for your good cheer.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 1:36 pm | Permalink
  5. Thanks for the reading suggestion, and for checking up on me. I’m fine — an occupational hazard of writing online, right? Plus it inspired me to invent a new word to describe getting taken to task on the internet: flog + blog = fblog! As in, “Whoa, dude, you really got a fblogging over at Scatterplot!” I am open to suggestions regarding pronunciation.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 3:45 pm | Permalink
  6. I have given up on purple prose, and taken up inventing words. See reply to Emily’s comment, above.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 3:46 pm | Permalink
  7. Yeah, I got it on a listserv last summer. Flogstserved?

    (It was a battle over whether our not our identity-group conference social should be organized around the gay marriage supreme court decision in California. You can imagine what side I was on. There do now exist on the internet some rather wonderful photos of me drunkenly getting the first slice of the social’s celebratory wedding cake. Those were the days…)

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 4:03 pm | Permalink
  8. mt

    Is there is sufficiently reasonable non-racist interpretation of the watermelon postcard to make it analogous to the NY Post cartoon? I don’t see one.

    Posted on 26-Feb-09 at 9:04 pm | Permalink
  9. I don’t know that I had a strict 1-to-1 analogy in mind, but thinking about your comment led me to this:

    I think that both the Post cartoon and the watermelon email respond to the threat Obama’s presidency poses to the dominant racial order. I think they both do so by putting Obama/African Americans back in their “proper” racially-subordinated place. I think both do this regardless of whatever else they might do.

    Posted on 27-Feb-09 at 10:41 am | Permalink
  10. I’m one of about only four people on Scatterplot arguing that the Post’s denial of deliberate racism was plausible, but I’d agree with mt that there’s no non-racist explanation of the watermelons (why watermelons and not pumpkins or any other vegetation) and that the mayor’s denial is just a flat out lie.

    Posted on 27-Feb-09 at 11:15 am | Permalink
  11. Watermelons and chimps have racist implications with real impact for actual human beings?! I’m shocked, shocked I say.

    I like fblogging as a neologism.

    Posted on 02-Mar-09 at 7:56 pm | Permalink
  12. i got your reference to “trauma” and feel the Scatterplot reaction was indicative of the sensitive nature of the discussion prior to you. i don’t like the psychoanalytic roots of the term, but it captures the individual and collective impact of racial stratification summarily. it seems as if the Scatterplot poster took your statement to mean that you were blaming Scatterplot (as a Sociology representative) for the failures of society to address the realities and consequences of racial inequality. he/she was hurt. understandable. no one wants to be called a “racist” explicitly or implicitly, especially people who feel they themselves are well-intentioned.

    this last point leads me to an understanding that must gain currency in contemporary America if we are to move beyond ourselves as a “nation of cowards” (AG Eric Holder, Feb. 18, ’09): racism is not about intentions. in fact, the most virulent forms of racism occur invisibly, as an inert structural force. this inert structural force embodies both cultural symbolisms of whole peoples (e.g., blacks as monkeys (see Joseph Grave’s The Emperor’s New Clothing) or blacks eat watermelons or Jews are rats (see Maus)) and the context of lived realities (e.g., racial residential segregation, racial differences in the quality of educational opportunities, racial profiling).

    yes, some racism is rooted in intention, but if we narrow the definition of racism as such we miss out on the transinstitutional and multidimensional nature and consequences of race and racial hierarchy. DuBois in The Philadelphia Negro and Omi and Winant in Racial Formation in the United States are two bodies of work that use this dual structural approach (cultural symbolisms and lived experiences); although, the blame for the articulation of the approach presented here, if proven to be navel grazing, florid, and/or garbage, should be put on me.

    Posted on 09-Mar-09 at 4:01 am | Permalink
  13. LOL the last line of your comment!

    I know this is a side point, but yes I also have come to some uses of psychoanalytic theory with a good amount of trepidation. My feeling is that the ideas can be a bit mobile, and taken from their strict Freudean roots and the problems Freud brings. But nonetheless there is some kind of prescriptive feeling in any use of pscyhoanalytic theory, and that makes me nervous (or neurotic?!) as well.

    And re: intentionality. Thank you for articulating this really clearly, it’s helpful for me, as well as pointing to the possibility of theorizing a “dual structural” approach. I just found out there’s a symposium at the U of Oregon next month commemorating the 25th anniversary of Omi & Winant’s book. The line-up looks pretty stellar.

    Posted on 09-Mar-09 at 12:48 pm | Permalink

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.